What is the Admissibility Hearing?
An admissibility hearing is a formal process where the Immigration Division of the Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada (IRB) determines whether an individual can legally enter or remain in Canada. This hearing typically occurs if the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) believes a person is inadmissible due to reasons such as criminal activity, security risks, or misrepresentation.
What Happens at an Admissibility Hearing?
During an admissibility hearing, a member of the Immigration Division will preside over the proceedings. The CBSA will present evidence to prove why they believe you are inadmissible.
You, or your legal counsel, will have the opportunity to respond, present your case, and provide evidence or witness testimony. After both sides have presented their arguments, the member will make a decision on whether you are admissible to Canada or not.
If you’re facing an admissibility hearing or have received a removal order, navigating the process can be challenging. Our experienced team is here to help you understand your options and guide you through every step. Contact us today to get the support you need to resolve your immigration issues effectively.
Admissibility Hearing Process
- Notice to Appear: You’ll receive a Notice to Appear, detailing the date and time of your hearing. All hearings are virtual, but you can request an in-person hearing if necessary.
- Preparation: Before the hearing, you’ll receive a package from the CBSA outlining the reasons for your potential inadmissibility. You may need an interpreter or legal representation, which should be arranged in advance.
- Hearing Day: The hearing begins with introductions and a check of communication needs. The CBSA presents its case first, followed by your defense. Witnesses may be called, and both sides can question each other.
- Decision: The Immigration Division member will decide if you are inadmissible or not. The decision may be delivered at the end of the hearing or sent to you by mail.
Admissibility Hearing Outcomes
- Not Inadmissible: If the member finds you are not inadmissible, you can stay or enter Canada. The CBSA can appeal this decision to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD).
- Inadmissible: If found inadmissible, you will receive a removal order. There are three types:
- Departure Order: Leave Canada within 30 days and confirm your departure with CBSA to avoid converting it into a Deportation Order.
- Exclusion Order: You cannot return to Canada for one year (or five years for misrepresentation) without special permission.
- Deportation Order: You are permanently barred from Canada unless you obtain an Authorization to Return to Canada (ARC).
Reasons for Inadmissibility
Canada upholds strict immigration laws to ensure its citizens’ and residents’ safety, security, and well-being. Admissibility is determined based on criteria that evaluate whether an individual poses any risks to the country.
When someone is deemed inadmissible, they are not allowed to enter or remain in Canada for specific reasons outlined in the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA).
Criminality and Serious Criminality
One of the most common grounds for inadmissibility is criminal activity, including crimes committed in Canada or abroad. Minor offenses, such as petty theft, might not always lead to inadmissibility, but more severe crimes, categorized as “serious criminality,” almost always do.
Examples of serious criminal offenses include assault, fraud involving significant sums of money, or drug trafficking.
A past criminal conviction can lead to problems at the border or during visa applications. Canadian authorities assess the equivalency of foreign convictions to Canadian law, so a crime that is considered minor in another country might still render someone inadmissible if it aligns with a serious offense under Canadian law.
Security Risks
Canada prioritizes national security. Individuals involved in espionage, terrorism, or efforts to overthrow a government are considered inadmissible. This includes active participants in groups with violent or extremist ideologies, as well as those who have funded or supported such organizations.
In some cases, individuals without direct involvement in such activities may still face scrutiny if they have indirect ties to groups that pose security risks. Canadian authorities thoroughly investigate these connections to ensure no potential threats are overlooked.
Human Rights Violations
Canada has a strong commitment to upholding human rights and does not allow entry to individuals associated with crimes against humanity. This includes participation in war crimes, genocide, or systematic human rights abuses. For example, individuals who held positions of authority in regimes known for atrocities may be deemed inadmissible, even if they didn’t personally commit crimes.
Past actions are closely examined, and individuals with documented roles in oppressive governments or organizations might be flagged. This applies to direct perpetrators and those who facilitated or supported such crimes.
Health-Related Reasons
Health-related inadmissibility arises when an individual’s condition is deemed a public health or safety risk or if their medical needs could excessively demand Canadian healthcare resources. Communicable diseases such as tuberculosis or untreated syphilis are typical examples of conditions that can lead to inadmissibility.
However, not all health issues result in exclusion. Canadian immigration authorities consider factors such as the individual’s recovery potential, treatment options, and whether their presence could affect the population’s health.
Misrepresentation
Providing false or misleading information during the immigration process is considered a serious violation. Misrepresentation includes lying about personal details, omitting critical information, or submitting fake documents. It undermines the integrity of the immigration system, and those guilty of misrepresentation may be barred from entering Canada for up to five years.
Financial Inability
Applicants who cannot prove they have sufficient funds to support themselves and their dependents during their stay may also be found inadmissible. Canada requires visitors, students, and workers to demonstrate financial stability to avoid burdening the country’s social welfare programs.
Legal Representation and Rights
Knowing your rights and the role of representation is crucial when facing an admissibility hearing. This process can determine whether you can enter or remain in Canada, so it’s essential to approach it with preparation and support.
Canadian immigration laws provide a framework to ensure fair treatment during the hearing process, but navigating these laws without assistance can be overwhelming.
Your Right to Legal Representation
One of the fundamental rights during an admissibility hearing is the right to legal representation. You are entitled to hire a lawyer or authorized immigration consultant. This representative can:
Advise you on the strength of the evidence presented by the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA).
Develop a defense strategy tailored to your case.
Legal representation isn’t mandatory, but having a professional advocate on your side often makes a significant difference. They are trained to identify legal arguments, challenge the evidence, and effectively present your case.
If you cannot afford legal representation, there may be options for legal aid depending on the province or territory where you reside. Exploring these options as soon as you receive notice of the hearing is important to ensure you have adequate time to prepare.
Access to Evidence
Another key right during an admissibility hearing is access to the evidence. Before the hearing, the CBSA must disclose the information and documents they plan to present. This allows you and your legal counsel to review the material and prepare your response. Examples of evidence might include:
- Criminal records or charges from your home country.
- Documents alleging misrepresentation or fraudulent activity.
- Security reports suggest involvement with prohibited organizations.
By law, you are entitled to see the full case against you. If any documents are unclear or missing, your legal counsel can request clarification or additional disclosures.
Right to an Interpreter
Language barriers should not impede your ability to participate in the hearing. You can request an interpreter if you are not fluent in English or French. This free service ensures you can fully understand and respond during the proceedings.
Conducting the Hearing
The hearing is structured to protect your rights and allow for a fair examination of the facts. The presiding member of the Immigration Division acts as an impartial decision-maker. They will:
- Allow both sides to present their arguments.
- Evaluate the credibility of the evidence and witnesses.
- Ensure that procedural fairness is maintained throughout.
You also have the right to present your evidence, call witnesses, and cross-examine those presented by the CBSA. These rights are vital in building a strong case.
Why Representation Matters
Legal representatives bring expertise and objectivity to your case. They can identify procedural errors, challenge inadmissible evidence, and highlight mitigating factors that may work in your favor. For example:
Your lawyer can demonstrate rehabilitation efforts if the case involves past criminal convictions.
In cases of alleged misrepresentation, they can provide context and clarify misunderstandings.
Potential Consequences of Inadmissibility
Being deemed inadmissible to Canada can have far-reaching effects on your personal, professional, and family life. The consequences extend beyond immediate removal and can influence your ability to travel, work, or reunite with loved ones.
The most immediate consequence of being found inadmissible is the issuance of a removal order. This legal order outlines the terms of your departure from Canada and dictates whether you can return. There are three primary types of removal orders:
- Departure Order: Individuals must leave Canada within 30 days and confirm their departure with the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA). Failing to do so can escalate the order into a deportation order, which carries stricter penalties.
- Exclusion Order: This prevents you from re-entering Canada for a specific period, typically one year. However, the exclusion period could be extended to five years for misrepresentation cases.
- Deportation Order: This is the most severe removal order, permanently barring an individual from returning to Canada unless they obtain Authorization to Return to Canada (ARC). Deportation orders are usually issued for serious criminality or security risks.
These orders take effect immediately after the hearing decision, and compliance is mandatory to avoid further legal issues.
Long-Term Effects on Immigration
A finding of inadmissibility often leaves a permanent mark on your immigration record. This record is accessible by other countries, particularly those that share information with Canada, such as the United States. As a result, inadmissibility in Canada may complicate your ability to secure visas or entry into other nations.
Even if you are eligible to apply for re-entry to Canada in the future, the application process becomes significantly more challenging. Immigration officials will scrutinize your case more closely, and you may need to demonstrate rehabilitation or address the circumstances that led to your initial inadmissibility.
Professional and Financial Impact
Inadmissibility often results in the immediate termination of privileges for individuals residing in Canada on work or study permits. Losing the ability to work or complete education disrupts personal and professional goals. In some cases, inadmissibility can lead to losing employment opportunities in other countries due to reputational damage.
The financial costs associated with removal, legal fees, and reapplication can be overwhelming. Moreover, if a deportation order requires you to leave behind personal assets, such as property or investments, the financial strain can be even greater.
Family Separation
A finding of inadmissibility can lead to significant emotional and logistical challenges in cases involving family sponsorship or accompanying dependents.
Families may be forced to live apart while resolving immigration issues, and children may face disruptions to their education and social lives. Spouses or partners relying on the primary applicant’s legal status may also lose their right to stay in Canada.
Social and Psychological Effects
The stress and uncertainty associated with being deemed inadmissible can have a profound impact on mental health. The process often involves stigma, feelings of rejection, and anxiety about the future. These emotional challenges are compounded when family members are also affected.
Mitigating the Consequences
While the consequences of inadmissibility are severe, there are measures that you can take to minimize your impact:
- Rehabilitation: Those with past criminal convictions can apply for rehabilitation to demonstrate that they no longer pose a risk.
- Authorization to Return to Canada (ARC): In cases involving a deportation order, an ARC allows individuals to reapply for entry under specific conditions.
- Legal Appeals: Some removal orders can be appealed to the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD), offering a chance to challenge the decision.
Appealing an Admissibility Decision
Being found inadmissible to Canada can feel like the end of the road, but there are avenues to challenge such decisions. The appeal process allows individuals to present new evidence, address procedural errors, or argue for a reconsideration based on specific circumstances. Understanding the appeal process is critical for making informed decisions about the next steps after an inadmissibility ruling.
Who Can Appeal?
Not everyone found inadmissible is eligible to appeal the decision. Typically, you may appeal if:
You are a permanent resident or a foreign national sponsored by a family member who is a Canadian citizen or permanent resident.
The inadmissibility decision was based on a removal order issued by the Immigration Division.
However, some individuals are excluded from appealing, including those deemed inadmissible for serious criminality, security risks, or human rights violations. If you fall under these categories, other legal remedies, such as applying for a judicial review, may still be available.
Where to File an Appeal
Appeals are always heard by the Immigration Appeal Division of the IRB. The IAD has the authority to:
- Overturn a removal order.
- Confirm the removal order.
- Refer the case back for reconsideration by the Immigration Division.
The IAD focuses not just on the legal basis for the initial decision but also considers the ruling’s broader implications, such as its impact on family reunification or humanitarian factors.
The Appeal Process
Submitting the Appeal:
You must file a formal appeal with the IAD within 30 days after receiving your removal order. Missing this deadline typically forfeits your right to appeal.
The appeal submission includes a comprehensive explanation of why the decision should be reconsidered and any supporting documents.
Preparing for the Hearing:
Gather evidence to support your case. This could include updated documentation, character references, or proof of rehabilitation if criminality was a factor.
Work closely with legal counsel to build a persuasive argument. They can help identify weaknesses in the original ruling or procedural errors that warrant a reversal.
The Hearing:
At the hearing, you can present the case and respond to the CBSA’s arguments.
Witnesses may be called to testify on your behalf, and both sides can cross-examine witnesses to challenge the credibility or relevance of their testimony.
The Decision:
The IAD may render a decision immediately after the hearing or reserve judgment to a later date.
If the appeal is successful, the removal order is canceled, and you retain your right to stay or enter Canada. If your appeal is denied, the original removal order remains in effect.
Grounds for a Successful Appeal
There are several factors that influence the success of an appeal:
Humanitarian and Compassionate Grounds: The IAD often considers whether the removal would cause you or your family undue hardship.
Procedural Errors: The IAD may overturn the decision if the initial hearing was not conducted fairly or key evidence was overlooked.
Rehabilitation or Change of Circumstances: Demonstrating that you no longer pose a risk to Canadian society can significantly strengthen your case.
Preparing for Success
Be Thorough: Provide complete and truthful information. Any inconsistencies can undermine your credibility.
Present Evidence Effectively: Highlight positive contributions, such as employment records, community involvement, or strong family ties in Canada.
Tips for Preparing for Your Hearing
The first thing to do is figure out why the Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) thinks you’re inadmissible. They’ll send you a package that explains their case against you. Take time to go through it carefully. It will include details like:
The specific reason you’re being called to the hearing (e.g., criminal history, misrepresentation, health concerns).
The evidence they plan to use, such as documents, records, or witness statements.
If any of it seems unclear or confusing, contact someone who knows the system, like an immigration lawyer or consultant. The sooner you fully understand their claims, the sooner you can plan how to respond.
Build Your Defense
Good preparation includes gathering evidence that supports your case. Think of anything that might show why the CBSA’s claims aren’t accurate or why you deserve to stay or enter Canada despite the concerns. Some helpful things might be:
Letters from people who know you well, like employers, community members, or religious leaders, speaking about your character.
Proof that you’ve turned your life around, like completing a rehabilitation program if your case involves criminality.
Medical reports showing improvement if health issues are part of the problem.
Evidence that you’ve followed all immigration rules and requirements.
Make sure your documents are complete and up to date and if needed, translated into English or French by a certified translator.
Don’t Go It Alone
While you can represent yourself at a hearing, having a legal expert on your side can make a huge difference. Immigration laws and hearings can get complicated, so having someone who knows the ropes is helpful. A lawyer or authorized immigration consultant can:
Review the CBSA’s evidence to find weak points in their case.
Help you gather and organize your evidence.
Speak on your behalf during the hearing and make sure your arguments are clear and strong.
If hiring a lawyer feels financially out of reach, check to see if legal aid is an option in your area. Acting early is key since legal professionals will need time to prepare your case.
Rehearse Your Case
It’s completely normal to feel nervous before your hearing, but practicing can help. Think about what questions you might be asked, and rehearse your answers. Some possible questions could include:
What steps have you taken to address the issues that led to your inadmissibility?
Why do you believe you should stay in or enter Canada?
How do you plan to comply with Canada’s laws moving forward?
Be honest and clear in your answers. If you’re working with a lawyer, they can help you practice and prepare.
Show Up Ready
On the day of the hearing, make sure you’re prepared. If it’s in person, arrive early. If it’s virtual, double-check your internet connection and set it up in a quiet, distraction-free space. Dress neatly to show that you take the process seriously.
Stay calm and respectful during the hearing, even if you feel upset or frustrated. The Immigration Division member will notice your behavior, and staying composed will work in your favor.
Keep These in Mind
Do:
Be polite and professional with everyone, including the CBSA representative.
Explain your points clearly and back them up with evidence.
Listen carefully and ask for clarification if you don’t understand something.
Don’t:
Exaggerate, leave out key details, or lie—this can hurt your case.
Interrupt or argue with anyone during the hearing.
Let nerves stop you from telling your side of the story.
The decision is usually given at the end of the hearing, but in some cases, it may be mailed to you afterward.
In Canadian courts, including admissibility hearings, evidence can be documents or testimony. All documents must be submitted in either English or French and provided to both the CBSA and the Immigration Division at least five days before the hearing.
If you cannot appeal, you may apply to the Federal Court of Canada for a judicial review. Legal advice is recommended, and actions must be taken quickly to meet deadlines.
Explore other services
Contact
- 211 Finch Avenue West, Toronto, ON, M2R 1M2
- +1-(647)864-4224
- [email protected]
Follow us
Stay Connected with Us on Social Media
Get in touch
Don’t hesitate to contact us for inquiries!
We’re here to help! For any questions, feedback, or support, please reach out via the form or email us at [email protected]. We’ll respond as soon as possible.